Restaurant Ratings
LISTED IN ORDER OF RATED QUALITY


RUGOSA (90.93 Extraordinary)
East Hampton; Modern American; Upscale; (631) 604-1550
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Perfection; Decor: Excellent)

THE 1770 HOUSE (87.45 Extraordinary)
East Hampton; Contemporary American; Upscale; (631) 324-1770
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Excellent; Decor: Excellent)

ROBERT'S (87.42 Extraordinary)
Water Mill; Italian Coastal; Upscale; (631) 726-7171
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Extraordinary; Decor: Very Good)

EAST BY NORTHEAST (85.43 Extraordinary)
Montauk; Pacific Rim/Asian Fusion; Upscale; (631) 668-2872
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Excellent; Decor: Extraordinary)

DELLA FEMINA (83.83 / Excellent)
East Hampton; Contemporary American/Italian; Upscale; (631) 329-6666
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Perfection; Decor: Very Good)

SAVANNA'S (83.33 / Excellent)
Southampton; Contemporary American; Upscale; (631) 283-0202
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Excellent)

EAST HAMPTON POINT (80.58 / Excellent)
East Hampton; Seafood/Continental; Upscale; (631) 329-2800
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Perfection)

NICK & TONI'S (78.42 / Excellent)
East Hampton; Mediterranean; Upscale; (631) 324-3550
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

ALMOND (77.83 / Excellent)
Bridgehampton; French Bistro; Upscale; (631) 537-8885
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

CASA BASSO (77.22 / Excellent)
Westhampton; Italian; Upscale; (631) 288-1841
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

THE AMERICAN HOTEL (76.50 / Excellent)
Sag Harbor; French/Continental; Upscale; (631) 725-3535
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

SUKI ZUKI (76.45 / Excellent)
Water Mill; Japanes/Sushi; Casual; (631) 726-4600
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

VILLA PAUL (75.58 / Excellent)
Hampton Bays; Italian; Upscale; (631) 728-3261
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

THE JAMES LANE CAFE AT THE HEDGES (74.50 / Very Good)
East Hampton; Mediterranean; Upscale; (631) 324-7100
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good to Very Good)

DAVE'S GRILL (74.17 / Very Good)
Montauk; Contemporary American/Seafood; Upscale; (631) 668-9190
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good to Very Good)

BAMBOO RESTAURANT & SUSHI LOUNGE (74.00 / Very Good)
East Hampton; Asian Fusion/Sushi; (631) 329-9821
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good to Very Good)

THE STATION BISTRO (72.28 / Very Good)
Water Mill; French Country; Upscale; (631) 726-3016
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

CROW'S NEST RESTAURANT & INN (71.89 / Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood/Traditional American; Family; (631) 537-3360
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

NAVY ROAD (71.35 / Very Good)
Montauk; Traditional American/Seafood; Family; (631) 668-1064
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

THE PALM RESTAURANT AT THE HUNTTING INN (71.33 / Very Good)
East Hampton; Traditional American/Seafood/Steaks; Upscale; (631) 324-0410
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good to Very Good)

SURFSIDE INN & RESTAURANT (68.83 / Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood / Traditional American; Family; (631) 668-5958
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good to Very Good)

MICHAEL'S AT MAIDSTONE PARK (67.25 / Very Good)
Springs; Contemporary American/Seafood/Steak; Family; (631) 324-0725
(Food: Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

ROWDY HALL (66.33 / Very Good)
East Hampton; English Pub; Family thru Upscale;
(Food: Good; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

CAFE MAX (65.67 / Very Good)
East Hampton; American/Continental; Upscale; (631) 324-2004
(Food: Good to Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

SEN (63.67 / Good to Very Good)
Sag Harbor; Japanese; Family; (631) 725-1774
(Food: Excellent; Service: Good; Decor: Very Good)

SAM'S RESTAURANT (63.67 / Good to Very Good)
East Hampton; Italian/Pizza; Family; (631) 324-5900
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good to Very Good)

LENNY'S ON THE DOCK (63.33 / Good to Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood; Family; (631) 668-2500
(Food: Very Good; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good / Harbor View)

GOLDBERG'S (62.60 / Good to Very Good)
East Hampton; Delicatessen; Family; (631) 329-8300
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good)

MÉSON OLE (61.17 / Good to Very Good)
Southampton; Mexican; Family; (631) 283-8574
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good)

MULTI AQUA CULTURE SYSTEMS ("THE LOBSTER FARM") (59.17 / Good to Very Good)
Amagansett (Promised Land); Seafood/Lobsters; Family; (631) 267-3341
(Food: Very Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Very Good)

BOSTWICK'S SEAFOOD GRILL (49.00 / Good to Very Good)
East Hampton; Seafood / Contemporary American; Family; (631) 324-1111
(Food: Good to Very Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Very Good)

GOSMAN'S INLET CAFE/TOPSIDE (48.67 / Good to Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood; Family; (631) 668-2549
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Very Good)

FELICE'S & ASTRO'S PIZZA (45.33 / Good)
Amagansett; Italian; Family; (631) 267-3339
(Food: Good to Very Good; Service: Good to Very Good; Decor: Fair)

THE OLD STOVE PUB (43.50 / Good)
Sagaponack; Greek/Steaks; Family; (631) 537-3300
(Food: Very Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Good)

BABETTE'S (41.83 / Good)
East Hampton; Contemporary American/Health; Family
(Food: Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Fair)

THE LOBSTER ROLL / "LUNCH" (39.00 / Good)
Napeague; Seafood; Roadhouse; (631) 267-3740
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Fair)

THE CLAM BAR AT NAPEAGUE (36.67 / Good)
Napeague; Seafood; Roadhouse; (631) 267-3740
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Fair)

CYRIL'S FISH HOUSE (36.33 / Good)
Napeague; Seafood; Roadhouse; (631) 267-7993
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Fair)

PIERRE'S (31.00 / Poor)
Bridgehampton; French; Upscale; (631) 537-5110
(Food: Good; Service: Terrible; Decor: Good)

IL CAPUCCINO (29.17 / Fair)
Sag Harbor; Northern Italian; Family; (631) 725-2747
(Food: Fair; Service: Fair; Decor: Good)

LA SUPERICA (29.00 / Fair)
Sag Harbor; Mexican; Family; (631) 725-3388
(Food: Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Poor)

TURTLE CROSSING (27.83 / Fair)
East Hampton; Southwestern/Barbecue; Family; (631) 324-7166
(Food: Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Good)


THE HAMPTONS WEB
TOP 9 for QUALITY OF FOOD

1.Rugosa East Hampton; Modern American
2.The 1770 House East Hampton; Contemporary American
3.Robert's Water Mill; Italian Coastal
4.Dave's Grill Montauk; Contemporary American/Seafood
5.Della Femina East Hampton; Contemporary American/Italian
6.Savanna's Southampton; Contemporary American
7.East By Northeast Montauk; Pacific Rim/Asian Fusion
8.Nick & Toni's East Hampton; Mediterranean
9.The American Hotel Sag Harbor; French/Continental

THE HAMPTONS WEB
TOP 10 for QUALITY OF SERVICE

1.Rugosa East Hampton; Modern American
2.Della Femina East Hampton; Contemporary American/Italian
3.The 1770 House East Hampton; Contemporary American
4.Robert's Water Mill; Italian Coastal
5.Rowdy Hall East Hampton; English Pub
6.Savanna's Southampton; Contemporary American
7.East By Northeast Montauk; Pacific Rim/Asian Fusion
8.Almond Bridgehampton; French Bistro
9.Bamboo Restaurant & Sushi Lounge East Hampton; Asian Fusion / Sushi
10.Nick & Toni's East Hampton; Mediterranean

THE HAMPTONS WEB
TOP 9 for DECOR, AMBIENCE & VIEW

1.East Hampton Point East Hampton; Seafood/Continental
2.East By Northeast Montauk; Pacific Rim/Asian Fusion
3.Casa Basso Westhampton; Italian
4.Robert's Water Mill; Italian Coastal
5.Villa Paul Hampton Bays; Italian
6.Savanna's Southampton; Contemporary American
7.The American Hotel Sag Harbor; French/Continental
8.The 1770 House East Hampton; Contemporary American
9.Rugosa East Hampton; Modern American

THE HAMPTONS WEB
"BEST IN THE VILLAGE" LIST

AmagansettD'Canela Latin
East HamptonRugosa Modern American
Hampton BaysVilla Paul Italian
MontaukEast By Northeast Pacific Rim/Asian Fusion
NapeagueThe Lobster Roll ("Lunch") Seafood
Quogue 
Sag HarborThe American Hotel French/Continental
SagaponackThe Old Stove Pub Greek/Steaks
Shelter Island 
SouthamptonSavanna's Contemporary American
SpringsMichael's at Maidstone Park Contemporary American/Seafood/Steak
Wainscott 
Water MillRobert's Italian Coastal
WesthamptonCasa Basso Italian

THE HAMPTONS WEB
"BEST OF CATEGORY" LIST

Asian FusionEast By Northeast Montauk
BarbecueTurtle Crossing East Hampton
Breakfast (Traditional)John Papa's Cafe East Hampton
ChineseDah Jong East Southampton
Coffee ShopJohn Papa's Cafe East Hampton
Contemporary AmericanRugosa East Hampton
ContinentalThe American Hotel Sag Harbor
DelicatessenGoldberg's East Hampton
Different Dining ExperienceMulti Aqua Culture Systems ("The Lobster Farm") Amagansett (Promised Land)
English PubRowdy Hall East Hampton
French BistroAlmond Bridgehampton
GreekThe Old Stove Pub Sagaponack
HealthBabette's East Hampton
ItalianCasa Basso Hampton Bays
Italian CoastalRobert's Water Mill
JapaneseSuki Zuki Water Mill
LatinD'Canella Amagansett
LobsterGosman's Dock Montauk
Lobster FarmMulti Aqua Culture Systems ("The Lobster Farm") Amagansett (Promised Land)
MediterraneanNick & Toni's East Hampton
MexicanMéson Ole Southampton
Pacific RimEast By Northeast Montauk
PastaConca d'Oro Sag Harbor
PizzaSam's Restaurant East Hampton
RibsThe Southampton Publick House Southampton
RoadhouseCyril's Fish House Napeague
SaloonThe Southampton Publick House Southampton
SandwichGoldberg's East Hampton
SeafoodEast Hampton Point East Hampton
SteakDella Femina East Hampton
Sunday BrunchEast Hampton Point East Hampton
Sushi/SashimiSuki Zuki Water Mill


Return to The Hamptons Web Dining Page

Return to The Hamptons Web Home Page


© 2010 The Hamptons Web, Inc., all rights reserved.
The Hamptons Web is maintained by Sagal Computer Systems.
Please email webmaster@hamptonsweb.com with comments and corrections.