Restaurant Ratings
LISTED IN ORDER OF RATED QUALITY

RUGOSA (90.93 Extraordinary)
East Hampton; Modern American; Upscale; (631) 604-1550
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Perfection; Decor: Excellent)

THE 1770 HOUSE (87.45 Extraordinary)
East Hampton; Contemporary American; Upscale; (631) 324-1770
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Excellent; Decor: Excellent)

ROBERT'S (87.42 Extraordinary)
Water Mill; Italian Coastal; Upscale; (631) 726-7171
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Extraordinary; Decor: Very Good)

EAST BY NORTHEAST (85.43 Extraordinary)
Montauk; Pacific Rim/Asian Fusion; Upscale; (631) 668-2872
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Excellent; Decor: Extraordinary)

DELLA FEMINA (83.83 / Excellent)
East Hampton; Contemporary American/Italian; Upscale; (631) 329-6666
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Perfection; Decor: Very Good)

SAVANNA'S (83.33 / Excellent)
Southampton; Contemporary American; Upscale; (631) 283-0202
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Excellent)

EAST HAMPTON POINT (80.58 / Excellent)
East Hampton; Seafood/Continental; Upscale; (631) 329-2800
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Perfection)

NICK & TONI'S (78.42 / Excellent)
East Hampton; Mediterranean; Upscale; (631) 324-3550
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

ALMOND (77.83 / Excellent)
Bridgehampton; French Bistro; Upscale; (631) 537-8885
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

CASA BASSO (77.22 / Excellent)
Westhampton; Italian; Upscale; (631) 288-1841
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

THE AMERICAN HOTEL (76.50 / Excellent)
Sag Harbor; French/Continental; Upscale; (631) 725-3535
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

SUKI ZUKI (76.45 / Excellent)
Water Mill; Japanes/Sushi; Casual; (631) 726-4600
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

VILLA PAUL (75.58 / Excellent)
Hampton Bays; Italian; Upscale; (631) 728-3261
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

THE JAMES LANE CAFE AT THE HEDGES (74.50 / Very Good)
East Hampton; Mediterranean; Upscale; (631) 324-7100
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good to Very Good)

DAVE'S GRILL (74.17 / Very Good)
Montauk; Contemporary American/Seafood; Upscale; (631) 668-9190
(Food: Extraordinary; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good to Very Good)

BAMBOO RESTAURANT & SUSHI LOUNGE (74.00 / Very Good)
East Hampton; Asian Fusion/Sushi; (631) 329-9821
(Food: Excellent; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good to Very Good)

THE STATION BISTRO (72.28 / Very Good)
Water Mill; French Country; Upscale; (631) 726-3016
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

CROW'S NEST RESTAURANT & INN (71.89 / Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood/Traditional American; Family; (631) 537-3360
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

NAVY ROAD (71.35 / Very Good)
Montauk; Traditional American/Seafood; Family; (631) 668-1064
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

THE PALM RESTAURANT AT THE HUNTTING INN (71.33 / Very Good)
East Hampton; Traditional American/Seafood/Steaks; Upscale; (631) 324-0410
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good to Very Good)

SURFSIDE INN & RESTAURANT (68.83 / Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood / Traditional American; Family; (631) 668-5958
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good to Very Good)

MICHAEL'S AT MAIDSTONE PARK (67.25 / Very Good)
Springs; Contemporary American/Seafood/Steak; Family; (631) 324-0725
(Food: Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Excellent)

ROWDY HALL (66.33 / Very Good)
East Hampton; English Pub; Family thru Upscale;
(Food: Good; Service: Excellent; Decor: Very Good)

CAFE MAX (65.67 / Very Good)
East Hampton; American/Continental; Upscale; (631) 324-2004
(Food: Good to Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Very Good)

SEN (63.67 / Good to Very Good)
Sag Harbor; Japanese; Family; (631) 725-1774
(Food: Excellent; Service: Good; Decor: Very Good)

SAM'S RESTAURANT (63.67 / Good to Very Good)
East Hampton; Italian/Pizza; Family; (631) 324-5900
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good to Very Good)

LENNY'S ON THE DOCK (63.33 / Good to Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood; Family; (631) 668-2500
(Food: Very Good; Service: Excellent; Decor: Good / Harbor View)

GOLDBERG'S (62.60 / Good to Very Good)
East Hampton; Delicatessen; Family; (631) 329-8300
(Food: Excellent; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good)

MÉSON OLE (61.17 / Good to Very Good)
Southampton; Mexican; Family; (631) 283-8574
(Food: Very Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Good)

MULTI AQUA CULTURE SYSTEMS ("THE LOBSTER FARM") (59.17 / Good to Very Good)
Amagansett (Promised Land); Seafood/Lobsters; Family; (631) 267-3341
(Food: Very Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Very Good)

BOSTWICK'S SEAFOOD GRILL (49.00 / Good to Very Good)
East Hampton; Seafood / Contemporary American; Family; (631) 324-1111
(Food: Good to Very Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Very Good)

GOSMAN'S INLET CAFE/TOPSIDE (48.67 / Good to Very Good)
Montauk; Seafood; Family; (631) 668-2549
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Very Good)

FELICE'S & ASTRO'S PIZZA (45.33 / Good)
Amagansett; Italian; Family; (631) 267-3339
(Food: Good to Very Good; Service: Good to Very Good; Decor: Fair)

THE OLD STOVE PUB (43.50 / Good)
Sagaponack; Greek/Steaks; Family; (631) 537-3300
(Food: Very Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Good)

BABETTE'S (41.83 / Good)
East Hampton; Contemporary American/Health; Family
(Food: Good; Service: Very Good; Decor: Fair)

THE LOBSTER ROLL / "LUNCH" (39.00 / Good)
Napeague; Seafood; Roadhouse; (631) 267-3740
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Fair)

THE CLAM BAR AT NAPEAGUE (36.67 / Good)
Napeague; Seafood; Roadhouse; (631) 267-3740
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Fair)

CYRIL'S FISH HOUSE (36.33 / Good)
Napeague; Seafood; Roadhouse; (631) 267-7993
(Food: Good; Service: Good; Decor: Fair)

PIERRE'S (31.00 / Poor)
Bridgehampton; French; Upscale; (631) 537-5110
(Food: Good; Service: Terrible; Decor: Good)

IL CAPUCCINO (29.17 / Fair)
Sag Harbor; Northern Italian; Family; (631) 725-2747
(Food: Fair; Service: Fair; Decor: Good)

LA SUPERICA (29.00 / Fair)
Sag Harbor; Mexican; Family; (631) 725-3388
(Food: Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Poor)

TURTLE CROSSING (27.83 / Fair)
East Hampton; Southwestern/Barbecue; Family; (631) 324-7166
(Food: Good; Service: Fair; Decor: Good)