Sagaponack Dining

THE OLD STOVE PUB 3516 Montauk Highway (631) 537-3300

Greek; Steaks. Located on the north side of Montauk Highway, between Bridgehampton and East Hampton. One cannot classify this restaurant as expensive or inexpensive. A large portion of the menu is traditional Greek cuisine, quite reasonably priced (cheap, even). But the house specialty is steak and that is what the in-crowd comes for, even though it is not-so-reasonably priced (the jump in price for this one item would make it appear that we have two separate restaurants here. Like Brooklyn's Peter Luger Restaurant, where only steak is served, the steak cooking technique is outstanding. Casual dress.

Hamptons Web Rating: 43.50 (Good)
Food: 68.25 (Very Good)
Service: 29.75 (Fair)
Decor: 32.50 (Good)