Sag Harbor Dining

5 Bay Street
(631) 725-9613
Peter and Pam Miller, Proprietors

Hamptons Web Rating: Unrated
Food: Unrated
Service: Unrated
Decor: Unrated

25 Main Street
(631) 725-3535

Continental. Old world style hotel and restaurant. Aside from excellent dining, the well-stocked cigar humidor offers by far the best selection of cigars on the East End. Watch for periodic cigar tastings and events (the fact that this is a hotel allows them to be more flexible with smoking laws). Charming, but the service is occasionally less refined than the prices and surroundings would dictate. Bar menu available from noon to 11:00pm 7 days a week. Full liquor license; indoor bar, cocktail lounge, cigar smoking room, outdoor cocktail porch.

Hamptons Web Rating: 76.50 (Excellent)
Food: 81.00 (Excellent)
Service: 65.00 (Very Good)
Decor: 83.00 (Excellent)

Main Street
(631) 725-3167

Pizzeria; Italian. Family restaurant featuring possibly the best portions of the best pasta on the East end; certainly the best Fettucine Alfredo in the world (including Alfredo's). Hidden behind your typical pizzeria (serving good pizza) is a charming dining room: that wonderful little neighborhood Italian restaurant that takes all the effort out of dining out, without sacrificing good food/atmosphere. Casual dress by all means.

Hamptons Web Rating: Unrated
Food: Unrated
Service: Unrated
Decor: Unrated

30 Madison Street
(631) 725-2747

Northern Italian. Unassuming locally popular family-style restaurant on the edge of Sag Harbor's shopping district. The more casual sister restaurant to Il Monastero in East Hampton. Open 5:30pm to 10:30pm (5:30pm to 11:00pm on weekends) for dinner only, 7 days a week, all year. AE, MC, V. Entree price range: $9.95 to $19.95. Reservations not accepted; full liquor license; no sit-down bar; take-out menu available.

Hamptons Web Rating: 29.17 (Fair)
Food: 31.50 (Fair)
Service: 23.00 (Fair)
Decor: 33.00 (Good)

Noyac Road
(631) 725-1116

Hamptons Web Rating: Unrated
Food: Unrated
Service: Unrated
Decor: Unrated

Main Street
(631) 725-3388

Mexican. Standard Mexican menu attracts local chile-heads. While the stuffed chiles are good, most of the fare is unexceptional Mexican cuisine. Lack of decor combined with poor accoustics and a generally noisy crowd does not make for light, pleasant dining. Casual dress.

Hamptons Web Rating: 29.00 (Fair)
Food: 44.00 (Good)
Service: 31.00 (Fair)
Decor: 12.00 (Poor)

23 Main Street
(631) 725-1774

Japanese. Probably the best sushi and sashimi bar on the East End. Also, fairly complete Japanese menu includes tempura, teriyaki, curries, and grilled tuna. Try their chirashi (very nice selection of sashimi over sushi rice). Excellent not-very-Japanese seafood chowders. No credit cards. Casual dress.

Hamptons Web Rating: 63.67 (Good to Very Good)
Food: 77.50 (Excellent)
Service: 44.50 (Good)
Decor: 69.00 (Very Good)

Main Street
(631) 725-9353


Hamptons Web Rating: Unrated
Food: Unrated
Service: Unrated
Decor: Unrated

Return to The Hamptons Web Dining Page

Return to The Hamptons Web Home Page

© 2009 The Hamptons Web, Inc., all rights reserved.
The Hamptons Web is maintained by Sagal Computer Systems.
Please email with comments and corrections.