Napeague Dining

CLAM BAR AT NAPEAGUE
Montauk Highway
(631) 267-6348

Seafood. Specializing in raw and prepared shellfish, fried calamari, chowders and other local seafood, this roadside clam bar allows for seasonal outdoor dining only. As busy between meals as during. The only serious negative is that when wind conditions are right, mosquitos can be vicious. Very casual dress.

Hamptons Web Rating: 36.67 (Good)
Food: 38.00 (Good)
Service: 45.00 (Good)
Decor: 27.00 (Fair)

CYRIL'S FISH HOUSE
Montauk Highway
(631) 267-7993

Seafood. Possibly the best of the seafood roadhouses along Montauk Highway between Amagansett and Montauk (although fans of The Lobster Roll will strongly disagree). Certainly, the Cajun Calamari is considerably tastier than the fried calamari at other spots. Cyril, the owner, is a self-admitted character who enjoys engaging patrons in political discussions of a conservative nature. Large outdoor and smaller indoor dining areas; full liquor license; sit-down bar.

Hamptons Web Rating: 36.33 (Good)
Food: 42.00 (Good)
Service: 37.00 (Good)
Decor: 30.00 (Fair)

THE LOBSTER ROLL ("LUNCH") Montauk Highway (631) 267-3740

Seafood. Very casual family-style roadside seafood house and clam bar, specializing in its lobster roll. Located on the South side of Montauk Highway between Amagansett and Napeague, this restaurant has built a loyal following. We would recommend it for a quick stop for steamers, chowder or raw shellfish, but the fried seafood platters are no better or worse than at any of the other roadhouses in the area. Casual dress; screened-in dining porch and outdoor picnic tables.

Hamptons Web Rating: 39.00 (Good)
Food: 44.50 (Good)
Service: 46.00 (Good)
Decor: 26.50 (Fair)